The tale of Chidima Adetshina, a South African-born contestant with Nigerian roots, continues to unfold in unexpected ways. After her tumultuous exit from the Miss South Africa 2024 contest, where accusations of xenophobia ran high, Chidima has now been invited by Ben Murray-Bruce, the CEO of Silverbird Group, to compete in the Miss Universe Nigeria pageant a move that has sparked outrage on both sides of the border.

For Chidima, this invitation is a second chance at the dream that was marred by controversy in her homeland. She accepted Murray-Bruce’s offer with heartfelt gratitude, seeing it as an opportunity to represent her heritage on a global stage. However, not everyone is thrilled with this decision.

In Nigeria, the reactions are mixed. Some Nigerians are up in arms, arguing that the opportunity to represent the country should be reserved for someone who is unquestionably Nigerian—a person who has long dreamt of standing on that stage. They fear that Chidima, whose mother has been embroiled in allegations of identity fraud, may bring more unwanted attention and controversy to Nigeria on the global stage. These critics believe that Chidima’s inclusion deprives other deserving contestants of their rightful place in the competition, potentially due to what they perceive as a hidden agenda.

On the other hand, some see Chidima’s participation as a chance for redemption. They are happy to see her given another opportunity to prove herself, despite the challenges she faced in South Africa. Yet, there is concern about the toll this might take on Chidima’s self-worth and confidence should she fail to secure the crown.

What’s most intriguing, however, is the hypocrisy that underlies this entire situation. Many Nigerians who condemned South Africans for saying Chidima wasn’t “South African enough” to compete in Miss South Africa are now questioning whether she is “Nigerian enough” to represent Nigeria on the global stage. The irony is not lost, as this debate brings to light the complex and often contradictory nature of national identity and belonging.

While the conversation rages on, it’s easy to forget the bigger picture: a young woman who dared to dream is being given another chance. Whether Chidima’s journey leads to triumph or further controversy, it’s clear that her story has struck a chord across the continent.

For those following this story, it remains to be seen how this chapter will unfold. But one thing is certain Chidima Adetshina’s journey is far from over, and this writer supports her fully.

By Edima Columbus